Cristin Milioti’s pretty face could be going to Hell.

Casper Kelly, who directed both Your Pretty Face is Going to Hell and the viral comedy/horror video Too Many Cooks for Adult Swim, has cast the star of HBO Max’s The Penguin in his upcoming horror film, Buddy.

Production for Buddy began this week in Ohio. Though no plot details are known, sources are calling the upcoming film as a “new experience in horror,” which makes sense given the extreme weirdness of Too Many Cooks. That video starts off parodying ’80s and ’90s sitcom opening sequences but after a (long) stretch morphs into a slasher film.

Kelly also directed the faux commercial featuring the “Cheddar Goblin” in the Nicolas Cage horror Mandy. Tyler Davidson and Drew Sykes are producing Buddy for Low Spark Films, with Jamie King co-writing the script with Kelly.

Milioti was just nominated for an Emmy award for her performance in The Penguin and recently starred in the Black Mirror episode USS Callister: Into Infinity from that show’s latest season.

There’s no word on when Buddy will be released yet.